Panel of Journalists at Elon University Media and Politics Conference Highlights Fairness and Fact-Checking

By Kellye Coleman

Persistence, a devotion to fairness and a sharpened pencil are essential tools for journalists and storytellers seeking to uncover the truth, according to a panel of local and national journalists participating in a media and politics conference at Elon University.

The panel discussion, titled “Challenges for Journalists,” featured journalists who have used a variety of methods to uncover important truths in local and national spheres and have overcome challenges in seeking the truth.

Be openminded

According to Andrew Curliss, investigative reporter for Raleigh’s News and Observer, the honest participation of key people in a story can be hard to come by. “Usually the people I’m reporting about don’t want my story to be accurate,” Curliss said. “That’s a real challenge.”

This was particularly true while he gathered information for a story about the corrupt practices of former North Carolina governor, Mike Easley, a story that led to a federal investigation.

However, Curliss has found that it is important to interview sources with an open mind, allowing them to tell the story. “It’s not like there’s something written ahead of time, and I just want to plug in a few holes,” he said.

Alex Goldman, producer of WNYC radio show “On the Media,” agrees with Curliss. “The important thing to do as an investigator is to start with a premise and do everything you can to prove that premise wrong,” he said. In his opinion, trying to find support for that premise will inhibit accuracy.

“The important thing to do as an investigator is to start with a premise and do everything you can to prove that premise wrong.” – Alex Goldman

Use a variety of sources

As a computer assisted reporting specialist for Propublica, a non-profit newsroom, Jennifer LaFluer has faced  her own set of problems. “Data, just like people, can lie. It can be inconsistent. It can have holes in it,” she said.

One key way to overcome this issue is pulling together sources. “For me, a lot of times getting to the true picture is by analyzing all of the data and having all of the data,” she said.

Goldman agrees. “We have a three-source rule on our show,” he said. “Make sure you use as many sources as you can.”

Public records left private

Pendulum editor Anna Johnson has found simply being a student presents it’s own challenges, particularly when requesting public records. “It can be challenging when you’re not taken seriously,” she said, revealing incidences when she has been people have laughed at her when requesting records.

According to Johnson, knowing the law and what individuals should have access to is key. “It’s important to know that sometimes when people say you can’t have information, that may not always be true,” she said.

Although some records are public, Curliss has found that reporters have to use their judgment:

Fact-Check!

Despite the varying challenges the panelists have faced when gathering news, all of them agree that fact-checking a story is essential. The members of the panel have unique methods to ensuring a stories facts are accurate.

The News and Observer staff must complete a “pencil check” for the stories they run, which means printing each stroy and checking facts. “Every fact, every paragraph, every quote is to be signed-off by hand,” he said. For a large story, this process could last for two weeks.

For LaFluer, not only is printing and checking by-hand imperative, but also checking sources of data against relevant documents. “Our stories run on our site, but then they also run with NPR, PBS, WNYC, The New York Times, other papers,” LaFluer said. “We want to make sure they’re right before they get there and are involved in the process all along.”

Be Smart News Consumers

The way social media has influenced the way young people consume news has shocked LaFluer. “The number of students that rely on things strictly from a Google search or somebody’s Facebook page is disturbing to me,” LeFluer said. She suggests using sites like Twitter as starting points for further discovery.

Similarly, Goldman relies on multiple, partisan-neutral sources:

For Curliss, paying attention to multiple news sources over time can allow one to consume news that’s consistently accurate.

“One of the things we try to do is to become a credible source of information,” Curliss said. “You know when the News and Observer, The New York Times or whoever it is put something out there, can you trust it or not? Hopefully, over time you know ‘Well, I can trust something from this outfit.'”

Advertisements

One thought on “Panel of Journalists at Elon University Media and Politics Conference Highlights Fairness and Fact-Checking

  1. Nice to see you covering this comprehensively.

    A couple of quick corrections for you:

    it is computer-assisted reporting

    The organization is Propublica, not Propublic:

    ProPublica
    Support ProPublica’s award-winning investigative journalism. … Catch up with ProPublica staffers on the popular social networking service. …
    http://www.propublica.org/

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s